Sign in

PAYCHEX INC (PAYX) Q2 2025 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • Q2 FY25 delivered solid fundamentals: Revenue $1.3169B (+5% YoY; +7% ex-ERTC), diluted EPS $1.14 (+6%), and operating margin 40.9% (+60 bps YoY). Management highlighted strong HR tech demand, robust PEO performance, and efficiency gains from AI/data initiatives .
  • Guidance largely maintained: FY25 total revenue growth 4%–5.5% (still includes ~200 bps ERTC headwind), MS growth 3%–4%, PEO & Insurance 7%–9% (now expected at the lower end), operating margin 42%–43% (now expected at higher end), tax rate 24%–25%, and adjusted EPS growth 5%–7% .
  • Q3 FY25 color: revenue growth 4.5%–5% (includes ~150 bps ERTC headwind) and operating margin 46%–47%; ERTC headwind anniversaries after Q3, which should help headline growth optics in the back half .
  • Estimate comparison: S&P Global Wall Street consensus data was unavailable at time of request; as such, beat/miss versus consensus cannot be assessed this quarter (S&P Global data unavailable).
  • Potential stock catalysts: reaffirmed FY guide with higher-end margin commentary, durable PEO momentum and retention, AI-enabled product innovation (HR Analytics Premium Plus; Recruiting Copilot), and post-ERTC optics improvement after Q3 .

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

What Went Well

  • Strong PEO momentum and share gains: “Our PEO is gaining share… contracted revenue in the PEO was up high double digits… client adds were up high double digits” (record retention; proposals up high double digits) .
  • Efficiency and margin expansion: Operating income +6% to $538M; operating margin 40.9% (+60 bps YoY), and excluding ERTC, margins would have expanded ~180 bps; FY25 margin now expected at higher end of 42%–43% .
  • AI/data-driven product traction: HR Analytics Premium Plus with GenAI assistant saw >80% engagement among early adopters; Paychex Flex Perks surpassed 100,000 employee purchases since launch, enhancing customer stickiness and monetization .

What Went Wrong

  • Florida at-risk medical plan (MPP) enrollment flat YoY; employees downgraded to lower-cost plans due to health inflation, creating pass-through revenue headwinds (no earnings impact) .
  • Other income net declined YoY ($5.6M vs $11.7M) given lower average corporate investment rates/balances, modestly dampening below-the-line contribution .
  • ERTC headwind persisted (~200 bps in Q2; ~150 bps expected in Q3), masking stronger underlying growth; reserve related to February prior-year ERTC sales was released (immaterial) and factored into guidance .

Financial Results

Headline Financials (Q4 FY24 → Q1 FY25 → Q2 FY25)

MetricQ4 2024Q1 2025Q2 2025
Total Revenue ($USD Billions)$1.295 $1.318 $1.317
Diluted EPS ($USD)$1.05 $1.18 $1.14
Operating Income ($USD Millions)$481.8 $546.7 $538.1
Operating Margin (%)37.2% 41.5% 40.9%
EBITDA ($USD Millions)$525.3 $585.8 $579.1

Notes: Company stated Q2 revenue growth was +7% excluding the ERTC expiration impact .

Segment and Key Line Items

Metric ($USD Millions unless noted)Q4 2024Q1 2025Q2 2025
Management Solutions Revenue$930.3 $961.7 $962.9
PEO & Insurance Solutions Revenue$326.6 $319.3 $317.9
Interest on Funds Held for Clients$38.2 $37.5 $36.1
Total Expenses$813.3 $771.8 $778.8
Other Income, net$10.0 $10.4 $5.6
Effective Tax Rate (%)22.8% 23.3% 24.0%

KPIs and Operating Data

KPIQ1 2025Q2 2025
Revenue Growth ex-ERTC+7% +7%
PEO Average Worksite Employee GrowthUpper single digits Upper single digits
Revenue RetentionNear/above pre-pandemic levels Improved, above pre-pandemic
Client LossesImproved YoY (less distress/out-of-business) Down YoY across segments
PEO Insurance AttachmentStrong; enrollment meeting/slightly exceeding expectations Increased mid-single digits attachment/participation; employees downgrading plans
Florida At-Risk MPP EnrollmentEnrollment tracking through Oct; strong medical attachment broadly Flat YoY; mix shift; leveraging agency options
Cash from Operations$546.1 (quarter) $841.1 (six months)
12-Month ROE (%)46% 46%
Shareholder Returns$457M (Q1 dividends+buybacks) $810M (six months)
Dividend per Share$0.98 (quarterly) $0.98 declared Jan 10, 2025

Guidance Changes

MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent GuidanceChange
Total Revenue GrowthFY254%–5.5% 4%–5.5% Maintained
Management Solutions GrowthFY253%–4% 3%–4% Maintained
PEO & Insurance Solutions GrowthFY257%–9% 7%–9% (lower end now expected) Tilted lower end
Interest on Funds Held for ClientsFY25$145M–$155M $135M–$155M Lowered lower bound
Other Income, netFY25$30M–$35M $30M–$35M Maintained
Operating MarginFY2542%–43% 42%–43% (higher end now expected) Tilted higher end
Effective Tax RateFY2524%–25% 24%–25% Maintained
Adjusted Diluted EPS GrowthFY255%–7% 5%–7% Maintained
Total Revenue GrowthQ3 FY25N/A4.5%–5% (incl. ~150 bps ERTC headwind) New quarter color
Operating MarginQ3 FY25N/A46%–47% New quarter color
Dividend per ShareCY Q1 2025$0.98 (declared) $0.98 (declared) Maintained

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

TopicQ4 2024Q1 2025Q2 2025Trend
AI/Technology InitiativesFocus on AI to drive service/productivity; data digitization (158 years of calls; 250 years of chats/emails) Launched Recruiting Copilot, Flex Perks, Flex Engage; strong innovation cadence HR Analytics Premium Plus with GenAI assistant; >80% engagement; Perks >100k purchases Accelerating
Macro/LaborTight labor; moderate growth; stabilization in small business wages/jobs Hiring within base positive & above expectations More optimism post-election but moderate growth; job openings rising; no recession signs Stable/moderate
PEO Momentum & Florida MPPStrong PEO WSE growth; double-digit PEO double-digit growth; enrollment meeting/exceeding expectations Share gains; contracted revenue & proposals up high double digits; Florida MPP flat; plan downgrades Strong, mix headwind in FL
Pricing/DiscountingStable; rationality improving Stable/slightly more price sensitivity; rational pricing Competitive market; price-value premium maintained; disciplined growth Stable
Interest Rates/FloatExpect cuts; funds held $150–$160M guide Updated to $145–$155M; other income $30–$35M Maintain $135–$155M; ~125 bps cuts embedded; minimal impact remaining Slight pressure
M&A PipelineRational valuations returning; tuck-ins possible Robust pipeline Largest pipeline in years; no M&A in guide; discipline emphasized Building
Regulatory/Legal——SMB top regulatory issues for 2025: tax sunsets, SECURE 2.0 auto-enroll, paid leave expansion, wage/hour overtime, state AI/privacy laws Heightened focus

Management Commentary

  • “Excluding the impact of the expiration of the ERTC program, revenue growth was 7% in the second quarter… Diluted earnings per share growth was 6% as we continually find ways to operate the company more efficiently” — CEO John Gibson .
  • “Operating margin… was up year-over-year approximately 60 basis points… excluding [ERTC] impact, operating margins would have expanded 180 basis points” — CFO Robert Schrader .
  • “Our PEO is gaining share… contracted revenue in the PEO was up high double digits… client adds were up high double digits… proposals were up high doubles” — CEO John Gibson .
  • “Premium Plus also has a Generative AI assistant and a chat interface… strong early adoption; over 80% of early adopters have actively engaged” — CEO John Gibson .

Q&A Highlights

  • Post-election sentiment and pipeline: More optimism but not yet translating into growth; job openings increased; desire to add employees remains strong .
  • PEO differentiation: Broad offering (PEO, ASO, agency) enables risk management and flexibility; share gains driven by plan options and advisory capabilities .
  • Florida MPP (at-risk) and mix: Flat enrollment; employees downgrading plans; company balanced growth with underwriting discipline, leveraging agency plans; minimal earnings impact .
  • Interest rate assumptions: ~125 bps of total cuts assumed this year; any remaining cut is unlikely to be material to FY25 result .
  • Pricing dynamics: Competitive but rational; price-value premium intact; disciplined growth and CAC discipline (e.g., Google spend vs lifetime value) .
  • Q3 outlook clarification: Revenue +4.5%–5% including ~150 bps ERTC headwind; operating margin 46%–47%; post-Q3, headline optics improve as ERTC headwind laps .

Estimates Context

  • S&P Global consensus estimates were unavailable at time of analysis; thus, comparison of actual Q2 FY25 revenue/EPS versus Wall Street consensus cannot be provided this quarter (S&P Global data unavailable).
  • Given guidance reaffirmation and higher-end margin commentary, near-term estimate revisions may focus on operating margin trajectory (toward high end of 42%–43%) and PEO growth tilting to lower end (7%–9%) due to Florida pass-through dynamics .

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Underlying growth and margin resilient despite ERTC headwind: +7% ex-ERTC revenue growth and +60 bps reported margin expansion signal solid core momentum .
  • PEO continues to be a secular engine: share gains, strong retention, and flexible insurance/agency options support durable lifetime value; Florida pass-through mix is managed for risk, not earnings .
  • Margin trajectory improving: FY25 operating margin now expected at high end (42%–43%), aided by digital adoption and AI-driven efficiencies; Q3 margin seasonally peaks (46%–47%) .
  • Product innovation as moat: HR Analytics Premium Plus (GenAI), Flex Perks, Recruiting Copilot broaden monetization and stickiness; early usage metrics encouraging .
  • Optics tailwind post-Q3: ERTC headwind anniversary should enhance reported growth optics, potentially catalyzing sentiment into back half .
  • Capital returns remain robust: $810M returned in six months; $0.98 quarterly dividend declared Jan 10, 2025; 12-month ROE ~46% underscores capital efficiency .
  • Watch list: interest-rate path impact on funds-held revenue, Florida MPP enrollment/mix, pricing rationality in mid-market, and M&A pipeline evolution as valuations normalize .

Best AI for Equity Research

Performance on expert-authored financial analysis tasks

Fintool-v490%
Claude Sonnet 4.555.3%
o348.3%
GPT 546.9%
Grok 440.3%
Qwen 3 Max32.7%